“Lactation Station,” a 2006 performance piece [see video here] by Toronto-based artist Jess Dobkin set out to challenge a deep cultural taboo. Dobkin invited audiences to taste samples of pasteurized human breast milk donated by a group of new mothers, and then facilitated a conversation between them. Six years later, Dobkin’s piece continues to stimulate spirited conversation—and grosses some people out, to be sure. But for Jews, it also raises a religious question: Is breast milk kosher? After all, humans aren’t kosher animals.
The medieval legal scholar Maimonides addresses this quandary directly: “Human milk is permitted to be eaten, even though the meat of a human is forbidden to be eaten.” (Mishneh Torah, Ma’akhalot Assurot 3:2) By way of explanation, one contemporary rabbi compares mother’s milk to honey—as a similarly exceptional case of kosher food derived from a non-kosher animal.
Maimonides does qualify his position a bit. While breast milk is kosher, it’s not kosher for an adult to drink it directly from the source. Why? “An adult who nurses from a woman’s breast is like one who nurses from a disgusting, impure animal.” Later commentaries explain that Maimonides’ unflattering comparison intended no offense to women: all he meant was that a suckling grownup might risk giving the impression that, as humans are technically non-kosher, the milk of all other non-kosher animals is permitted as well.
The bottom line: Breast milk must be expressed into a container before drinking. You know, if you’re into that.
Help ensure Jewish news remains accessible to all. Your donation to the Jewish Telegraphic Agency powers the trusted journalism that has connected Jewish communities worldwide for more than 100 years. With your help, JTA can continue to deliver vital news and insights. Donate today.