JTA: The Global News Service of the Jewish People

Mark Zivin

About Me

Ardent Reconstrutionist and nuevo political activist.
Believes in that Jewish values need to be applied universally.
Unfortunately, Ends still do not justify Means.

Basic Info

Member since:
07/11/2006
Last Logged In:
09/28/2009
Age:
58
Gender:
Male
From:
Evaston, IL

Posted in: Op-Ed: Choose civility

Hear, hear. As one who has apologized more than a couple of times and who, hopefully, now is calmer, wiser and perhaps a better teacher, thank you for this excellent piece.

Posted in: Stop at the fold

I don't believe that Cohen was "demonizing" Israel - but rather reacting to very real military exercises by IDF, comments made by PM Netanyahu and others in his cabinet, and the general Israeli public support for a pre-emptive strike against Iranian nuclear facilities. I concur with Mr. Cohen: "To avoid that nightmare Obama will have to get tougher with Israel than any U.S. president in recent years." I will grant you that the following sentence: "It’s time." Is editorial in nature - and not necessary within the context of what I think is a well considered column.

Posted in: Roger Cohen spars with Iranian Jewish expats

My kippah goes off to all involved. For Roger Cohen to be willing to personally go to answer his critics face-to-face, to Rabbi Wolpe for maintiaining decorum, and to JTA and Mr. Tugend for the report. Our country has spent the last five years pursuing a war that was based on inadequate information, study and/or debate. Shame on us if we make these same mistakes with Iran. I urge all to do a little bit of research about the history of Iran, its past relations with Israel and particularly its actions since 1978. I believe that the picture one sees won't be pretty - but if viewed objectively - will lead one to reject comments like Steve's (which arguably reflect the thoughts of many if not most Americans) out of hand. I would argue that we have much more to gain by trying to seek an alliance with Iran rather than trying to destroy it - but that is another story.

Posted in: Op-Ed: Hillary Clinton's troubling transformation

Surely, Mr. Klein is being either naive or disingenuous for not recognizing that the position, function and influence of Secretary of State is far different from that of US Senator. The same can be said for the politics of each position. It seems that Mrs. Clinton is indeed taking her position seriously and suppressing her personal views in favor of the Administration's views. So, Mr. Klein can continue to disagree with those policies, but only comes across as silly in his feigned characterization of this as a change in her personal point of view.

Posted in: Roger Cohen reality check

"Does this mean the civilized peoples of the world -- that is, those of us who don't make a goal of killing innocent civilians, women and children -- ought to engage and compromise with them?" I think a reasonable answer is: "If one has confidence in both our power and the correctness of our point of view, we should have nothing to fear by engaging with those whose views we disagree with (and even abhor)." Lack of willingness to engage seems to me ot be a sign of weakness - not a sign of either strength or principle. "As for the blockade of the strip -- Gaza is enemy territory controlled by a radical Islamist group that represses its own population and is bent on Israel's destruction. Why should Israel open its borders to Gaza or encourage Egypt, Gaza's other neighbor, to do so?" Again, the answer lies in seeking a long-term permanent solution to this problem that, like an infection, unless dealt with at its root causes, will continue to fester until it kills the organism that controls it.

View all comments »

I forgot my password
Get JTA's free Daily Briefing

RSS Feed Breaking News

Updated 11/20/09 @ 11:30AM EDT

Get JTA alerts via Twitter · Facebook

View All