JTA: The Global News Service of the Jewish People

JGMotek

Basic Info

Member since:
04/10/2006
Last Logged In:
09/30/2009

Posted in: Leonard Cohen, home at last

Add Melbourne, Australia, to the list of places where Leonard Cohen easily sold out a stadium. Mind you, I don't think that the basic premise of this factor is appropriate: Cohen's music is actually best appreciated in a slightly smaller venue. I don't think that the fact that he plays at them in the US means that he would be unable to sell out a stadium in a given large city if he chose to do so. I know I'm not the only fan who has been following him since the hit Suzanne many years ago. Although I know that touring at this age would not have been his choice but was forced on him by the embezzlement of his financial advisors, it's still phenomenal to see someone at his age still so enthusiastic about his music and still able to deliver what was probably the best concert I've ever seen.

Posted in: Building around a synagogue, development aims to build a community

I actually don't think this is "the first subdivision of its kind." I visited San Antonio, TX, several years ago and Congregation Rodfei Shalom seemed to me to be in a dedicated subdivision. It had its own eruv, the synagogue was on Sholom Drive, and the large semicircular street surrounding the subdivision was named Sholom Place.

Posted in: Rabbi in Australia charged with fraud

Knowing someone who went to the school doesn't seem to me to provide proof that the charges are baseless. How would anyone attending the school know whether the administration had submitted false attendance records? In order for the case to be brought, some evidence had to be presented.

Posted in: O.U. defends White House Chanukah card

I was one of the people who passed the photo of the card to some friends - I don't think anyone can deny that someone in the White House made a large faux pas. However, I disagree with people who are making the story bigger than it is by implying that it is evidence of general cultural insensitivity or indication of Bush's Israel policy or something. As for mixed cards or Xmas cards sent to friends who are identifiably Jewish, I'm not as accepting of that sort of thing. Chanukah is its own holiday and the fact that it happens to occur at roughly the same time as Xmas on the calendar doesn't mean they should be pushed together. "Getting along" doesn't mean making everything into a friendly ecumenical lump -- it means respecting everyone's culture and being sensitive to differences in belief.

Posted in: Isn't Miss Manners Jewish?

I disagree with the premise of this column, especially the invocation of Miss Manners (who is indeed Jewish, btw). She would agree that someone in the White House made a large faux pas in sending out Chanukah cards with Christmas symbolism on them. Pointing that out is not necessarily making it symbolic of Bush's policies on Israel or a lack of cultural sensitivity in general. (I agree that it's ludicrous to try to make the story bigger than it is.) Someone screwed up in a very noticeable way. Other people noticed the screw-up and reported on it. End of story.

View all comments »

I forgot my password
Get JTA's free Daily Briefing

RSS Feed Breaking News

Updated 11/20/09 @ 11:30AM EDT

Get JTA alerts via Twitter · Facebook

View All