<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<rss version="2.0"
    xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
    xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
    xmlns:admin="http://webns.net/mvcb/"
    xmlns:rdf="http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#"
    xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"> 
    
<channel>
    

    <title>Remembering Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg</title>
    <link>http://jta.org/ENTRY_PERMALINK_HERE/for-gabi-and-rivki-in-blessed-memory/</link>
    <description>A friend remembers the Chabad emissaries killed in the Mumbai attacks.</description>
    <dc:language>en-us</dc:language>
    <dc:creator>bholtzman@jta.org</dc:creator>
    <dc:rights>Copyright 2008</dc:rights>
    <dc:date>2008-11-28T;18:15:00-05:00</dc:date>
    <admin:generatorAgent rdf:resource="http://www.pmachine.com/" />
 


    <item>
      <title>Comment by Sangram Mahapatra</title>
      <link>sangramkemah@gmail.com</link>
      <description>Being a citizen of India, I truly feel very sad that this terrorist attack has happened in one of our cities and the government allowed it to happen even after having intelligence reports and warnings of impending terrorist attacks. The plight of little moshe who was orphaned even before his second birthday is really heart warming and painful.


India is a country which takes great pride on showing amiable hospitality to guests and tourists. Someone  coined the term &#8220;atithi devaa&#8221; which means &#8220;guests are Gods&#8221;. I guess that person must be churning in his grave because he has been proved wrong again and again. Tourists are ogled at, heckled, cheated by overcharging, females are molested and raped. And now, they are being killed by terrorists. If they do not get any security and are treated badly, why should they even come to visit India? And that will be truly detrimental to tourism in india.


I was shocked to read that an Israeli search and rescue team had come to mumbai but were not allowed to carry out an operation. They would definitely have done a better job than our own forces and little moshe would still have his parents with him. I am truly ashamed of the goverment&#8217;s inability to fight terror and stop such carnages from occurring.


May God help us all in our fight against terror !!! May we all be united in our efforts to defeat terrorist forces !!!</description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Being a citizen of India, I truly feel very sad that this terrorist attack has happened in one of our cities and the government allowed it to happen even after having intelligence reports and warnings of impending terrorist attacks. The plight of little moshe who was orphaned even before his second birthday is really heart warming and painful.
</p>
<p>
India is a country which takes great pride on showing amiable hospitality to guests and tourists. Someone  coined the term &#8220;atithi devaa&#8221; which means &#8220;guests are Gods&#8221;. I guess that person must be churning in his grave because he has been proved wrong again and again. Tourists are ogled at, heckled, cheated by overcharging, females are molested and raped. And now, they are being killed by terrorists. If they do not get any security and are treated badly, why should they even come to visit India? And that will be truly detrimental to tourism in india.
</p>
<p>
I was shocked to read that an Israeli search and rescue team had come to mumbai but were not allowed to carry out an operation. They would definitely have done a better job than our own forces and little moshe would still have his parents with him. I am truly ashamed of the goverment&#8217;s inability to fight terror and stop such carnages from occurring.
</p>
<p>
May God help us all in our fight against terror !!! May we all be united in our efforts to defeat terrorist forces !!!
</p>]]></content:encoded>
    <dc:date>2009-11-08T;03:12:00-05:00</dc:date>
    </item>

    <item>
      <title>Comment by Zev Brown</title>
      <link>chesssed@gmail.com</link>
      <description>Mumbai &#45; India situation  is probably one of the most tragic happening in our life time , it&#8217;s painful  to  comment on,  its so sad for all of us no difference if we knew the victims or not, its a loss for all of Klall Yisroel. May Hahem give their families and us comfort; help lead us to the ultimate Geulah in the near future, Amen.


I was thinking what lesson can I take from this tragedy for my self, please allow me to share a couple of points that I have derived from  this situation, to  try and better myself, I am not trying to point fingers at any one, I&#8217;m simply thinking out loud. 


First, We always have to remember what Chazel teach us, that NOTHING ever happens in the world by itself, everything that happened since the first moment of creation is all done and approved by Hashem Yisborch.


Second, As Jews we have to believe that what ever happens in our lifetime is good for us, even though we can&#8217;t see how something so tragic could possibly be considered good, but as we know that it&#8217;s Hashems doings it must be good for us, Hashems ways are only good he is a Ruchum V&#8217;chunun,   there has to be something &#8220;good&#8221; for us hidden in every difficult situation that we are not on a level to imagine yet. 


Third, The people who Hashem ended their life so suddenly must have been very great &#45; special people, holy Neshomes, they have tremendous Zechusim, as a amall example, they where able to unite Klall Yisroel  have all of us, no matter of our background, from all around the globe, Daven for their safety etc. 50 &#45; 60 hours around the clock, when was the last time that we all felt so close to each other having Yiden all over the world pray so much, same time, for the same topic to Hashem.


Forth, Where did it happen? in a Bais Hamedresh a Shul building: lets examine our selves and see if  we are careful with the full amount of respecting one has to have for a Shul / Bais Medresh as it says in Shulchan Aruch?&amp;nbsp; What percentage of us can honestly say that we go to Shul JUST to Daven and not to socialize? Are we on guard not to Shmuz or not to answer our Cell / Mobil phones during Davening? Do we pray with enough Kavonah? How many keep quiet during Laning when we read from the holy Torah? (and don&#8217;t join the Kiddush club) sad to say,  I have visited places that there is so much  talking during Davening that&#8217;s its a Chilul Hashem to step into a so called Shul&#8230;  So why do we wonder why Hashem is showing us so much anger.


Fifth, One or more of the Kedoshim at the seen was a Mashgiach for a very reliable Kashrus organization; I think it time that we are careful what we eat and whom we can trust to certify our foods, what foods enter our homes.&amp;nbsp; We can&#8217;t go with the attitude when I go to a Shimcha / Kidush / Hotel / Restaurant etc. I rely totally on the Mashgiach no matter who he is, we have to go and investigate the kitchen situation see whom we are relying on, would I rely on him or her for my business advice too? Or if we hear that a cretin product is questionable do we care, or our attitude is: well it has a Kosher symbol on the packaging it&#8217;s enough for me, the rest it&#8217;s not my problem. 


Sixth, The Kedoshim where reported as hostages for some time, WHY DID HASHEM MAKE THIS into a HOSTAGE SITUATION? Maybe the strong message 

is:&amp;nbsp;  Hashem is crying out to us and saying: I (Hashem) am hostage for &#8220;two thousand years&#8221; please turn back to me, do Teshuva from the bottom of your hearts, get me back to the Bais Hamikdosh, A.S.A.P. Hashem is in great pain, being in Golus such a long time is not easy, he is waiting for us to repent, have Achdus and greet Moshiach.


May we all use this horrifying experience to get closer to Hashem, do Teshuva obey our holy Torah, and be Zocha to see with our own eyes the Geulah in the near future.</description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Mumbai - India situation  is probably one of the most tragic happening in our life time , it&#8217;s painful  to  comment on,  its so sad for all of us no difference if we knew the victims or not, its a loss for all of Klall Yisroel. May Hahem give their families and us comfort; help lead us to the ultimate Geulah in the near future, Amen.
</p>
<p>
I was thinking what lesson can I take from this tragedy for my self, please allow me to share a couple of points that I have derived from  this situation, to  try and better myself, I am not trying to point fingers at any one, I&#8217;m simply thinking out loud. 
</p>
<p>
First, We always have to remember what Chazel teach us, that NOTHING ever happens in the world by itself, everything that happened since the first moment of creation is all done and approved by Hashem Yisborch.
</p>
<p>
Second, As Jews we have to believe that what ever happens in our lifetime is good for us, even though we can&#8217;t see how something so tragic could possibly be considered good, but as we know that it&#8217;s Hashems doings it must be good for us, Hashems ways are only good he is a Ruchum V&#8217;chunun,   there has to be something &#8220;good&#8221; for us hidden in every difficult situation that we are not on a level to imagine yet. 
</p>
<p>
Third, The people who Hashem ended their life so suddenly must have been very great - special people, holy Neshomes, they have tremendous Zechusim, as a amall example, they where able to unite Klall Yisroel  have all of us, no matter of our background, from all around the globe, Daven for their safety etc. 50 - 60 hours around the clock, when was the last time that we all felt so close to each other having Yiden all over the world pray so much, same time, for the same topic to Hashem.
</p>
<p>
Forth, Where did it happen? in a Bais Hamedresh a Shul building: lets examine our selves and see if  we are careful with the full amount of respecting one has to have for a Shul / Bais Medresh as it says in Shulchan Aruch?&nbsp; What percentage of us can honestly say that we go to Shul JUST to Daven and not to socialize? Are we on guard not to Shmuz or not to answer our Cell / Mobil phones during Davening? Do we pray with enough Kavonah? How many keep quiet during Laning when we read from the holy Torah? (and don&#8217;t join the Kiddush club) sad to say,  I have visited places that there is so much  talking during Davening that&#8217;s its a Chilul Hashem to step into a so called Shul&#8230;  So why do we wonder why Hashem is showing us so much anger.
</p>
<p>
Fifth, One or more of the Kedoshim at the seen was a Mashgiach for a very reliable Kashrus organization; I think it time that we are careful what we eat and whom we can trust to certify our foods, what foods enter our homes.&nbsp; We can&#8217;t go with the attitude when I go to a Shimcha / Kidush / Hotel / Restaurant etc. I rely totally on the Mashgiach no matter who he is, we have to go and investigate the kitchen situation see whom we are relying on, would I rely on him or her for my business advice too? Or if we hear that a cretin product is questionable do we care, or our attitude is: well it has a Kosher symbol on the packaging it&#8217;s enough for me, the rest it&#8217;s not my problem. 
</p>
<p>
Sixth, The Kedoshim where reported as hostages for some time, WHY DID HASHEM MAKE THIS into a HOSTAGE SITUATION? Maybe the strong message 
<br />
is:&nbsp;  Hashem is crying out to us and saying: I (Hashem) am hostage for &#8220;two thousand years&#8221; please turn back to me, do Teshuva from the bottom of your hearts, get me back to the Bais Hamikdosh, A.S.A.P. Hashem is in great pain, being in Golus such a long time is not easy, he is waiting for us to repent, have Achdus and greet Moshiach.
</p>
<p>
May we all use this horrifying experience to get closer to Hashem, do Teshuva obey our holy Torah, and be Zocha to see with our own eyes the Geulah in the near future.
</p>]]></content:encoded>
    <dc:date>2009-11-08T;03:12:00-05:00</dc:date>
    </item>

    <item>
      <title>Comment by Nandarani</title>
      <link>aclearblessing@yahoo.com</link>
      <description>I got to know &#8220;Gavi and Rivki&#8221; over the last 36 hours by reading the New York Times.&amp;nbsp; I awoke today, in Hawaii, and checked the Times, and learned what happened to them and to you, the Jewish community and particularly BROOKLYN.&amp;nbsp; I am writing because I wanted some kind of forum to express my feelings:&amp;nbsp; I&#8217;m not Jewish but since I am from New York and have worked with many wonderful Jewish people, I want to express my strong  feelings of &#45; wanting to let the community in Brooklyn, and the parents, friends and relatives know that someone (many people actually I am sure) cares a LOT about you now.&amp;nbsp; I am sure Rivki and Gavi are fine and it is a miracle about the survival of their son.&amp;nbsp; I hope to write to the New York Times to ask them to do follow up stories on the nurse/cook, and the son Moshe.&amp;nbsp; The story of Rivki and Gavi it seems could be made into a movie.&amp;nbsp; This entire thing reminded me of Daniel Pearl.&amp;nbsp;  I am sorry to bring that up but it is the truth.&amp;nbsp;  With aloha.&amp;nbsp; Nandarani</description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I got to know &#8220;Gavi and Rivki&#8221; over the last 36 hours by reading the New York Times.&nbsp; I awoke today, in Hawaii, and checked the Times, and learned what happened to them and to you, the Jewish community and particularly BROOKLYN.&nbsp; I am writing because I wanted some kind of forum to express my feelings:&nbsp; I&#8217;m not Jewish but since I am from New York and have worked with many wonderful Jewish people, I want to express my strong  feelings of - wanting to let the community in Brooklyn, and the parents, friends and relatives know that someone (many people actually I am sure) cares a LOT about you now.&nbsp; I am sure Rivki and Gavi are fine and it is a miracle about the survival of their son.&nbsp; I hope to write to the New York Times to ask them to do follow up stories on the nurse/cook, and the son Moshe.&nbsp; The story of Rivki and Gavi it seems could be made into a movie.&nbsp; This entire thing reminded me of Daniel Pearl.&nbsp;  I am sorry to bring that up but it is the truth.&nbsp;  With aloha.&nbsp; Nandarani
</p>]]></content:encoded>
    <dc:date>2009-11-08T;03:12:00-05:00</dc:date>
    </item>

    <item>
      <title>Comment by Lindsay Stricke</title>
      <link>lkstricke@gmail.com</link>
      <description>Thank you Ben for sharing this. I agree that they were brave soldiers who faced all of life&#8217;s challenges with devotion to Judaism and love for people.&amp;nbsp; My fiance Will and I spent three months in Mumbai in the Spring, and we went to Gavi and Rivki&#8217;s for shabbat dinner many times and spent Passover seder and dinners with them.&amp;nbsp; I am so horrified and saddened by this tragic, tragic loss to the whole world.&amp;nbsp; Their courage and generosity were felt by all who visited, stayed and ate with this beautiful family.&amp;nbsp; May we only remember them with blessing.</description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Thank you Ben for sharing this. I agree that they were brave soldiers who faced all of life&#8217;s challenges with devotion to Judaism and love for people.&nbsp; My fiance Will and I spent three months in Mumbai in the Spring, and we went to Gavi and Rivki&#8217;s for shabbat dinner many times and spent Passover seder and dinners with them.&nbsp; I am so horrified and saddened by this tragic, tragic loss to the whole world.&nbsp; Their courage and generosity were felt by all who visited, stayed and ate with this beautiful family.&nbsp; May we only remember them with blessing.
</p>]]></content:encoded>
    <dc:date>2009-11-08T;03:12:00-05:00</dc:date>
    </item>

 
</channel>
</rss>